New Carlisle, OH Real Estate

New Carlisle OH Real Estate Overview

Search homes for sale in New Carlisle, OH for free. View all 62 listings available in New Carlisle with an average price of $184,854. See Maps, Photos, and More.

New Home, New Carlisle

New Carlisle, Ohio is the perfect city for those who truly value a caring community that really gives back to the neighborhood. Home to many churches of various denominations, this religious based community often provides fun community activities for the entire family, as well as many volunteer based activities for those who wish to give back to their community. For example, many of New Carlisle’s churches provide free hot meals to those in need on a weekly basis.

If you are looking for a place to call “home” rather than just a house in any old neighborhood then New Carlisle will be perfect for you. New Carlisle is truly unique with its caring and giving community and welcoming residents. You will immediately feel right at home in this friendly town and will be proud to call such a wonderful community your home. Check out our available homes in New Carlisle now to find your future home!




Open Houses


Short Sales







New Carlisle OH Real Estate Stats

Average Price in New Carlisle: $209,654  County Average: $175,104

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in New Carlisle: $41  County Average: $43

Average Walkscore in New Carlisle: 31  County Average: 29

Average Year Built in New Carlisle: 1947  County Average: 1949

Average Days on Website in New Carlisle: 125  County Average: 105

New Carlisle OH Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhoods in New Carlisle OH

Mrs Northwood Sub Park Layne Manor
Silverlake Estates Stockstill Terra Villa
Valley View Estates

Areas in New Carlisle OH

Clark-Bethel Twp Clark-Pike & German Dayton North
Miami-Bethel SD

Most Popular Listing

Popular New Carlisle Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive New Carlisle Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap New Carlisle Real Estate


Listings in New Carlisle

Pristine farm! this beautiful 22 acre horse farm has been completely restored...

Value price lot in the twin creek development in New Carlisle...

Nice home on a larger lot with a 1.5 car, heated garage...

excellent traffic/visibility at one of the busiest intersections in New Carlisle. available immediately....

Yes.....this house needs some tlc inside. but check out all these updates - lennox gfa furnace & central air(2013), chimney liner(2013), top part of roof(2010), 10' x 16' shed w/ metal roof(2012), large blacktop drive(2011), hot water heater(2014), vinyl siding(2004), toilet(2016), & more updates...

Very nice country ranch style home featuring 3 bedrooms,family room,one & a half baths,full basement ,2 car attached garage & all sitting on over 1 acre in tecumseh school district...

Nice building lot located on quite road in pike township...

Opportunity awaits, hurry while the season is still upon us to get set up for the New year with a 20 acre, 13 of it woods, homestead featuring brick 2 story with 2 master suites, 3 full baths 2 florida/sunrooms off the master bedrooms huge family room great room and very large space to make the kitchen you always wanted...

As your turn the key you will notice beautiful oak wood flooring...

Ed lot in the beautiful twin creek development in New Carlisle. if you a...

This home is move in ready. New roof, New gutters, New carpet, Newer kitchen tile and cabinets as well as being painted throughout...

Well maintained ranch home with 3 bedrooms, huge kitchen/dining room combo, big living room, 17 x 16 master suite, large covered patio and big storage shed w/ loft...

L fenced rear yard. it is convenient to downtown New Carlisle. with some tlc this will make someone a great place to live!...

Great 3.5 acre lot in a cul-de-sac....

Classic curb appeal & totally polished custom built home...

Nice brick country home sitting on approximately 2...

great central location on sr 235/mcadams dr. just north of i-70 and just south of downtown New Carlisle. convenient access to/from sr 235, us 40 and i-70. tenant mix includes fulmer's/co...

Mrs. clean lives here! this home shows very well...

Pristine farm! this beautiful 22 acre horse farm has been completely restored...

Great building lot. 1.75 ac with small pond....

Chat with us now!

A real live chat operator is online now! We can immediately get your questions answered or make sure we get it to an agent who can.

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

Realty Central
6728 Loop Road, Suite 201
Centerville, OH

Other Locations